Avoiding the Seven Deadly Sins of Outsourcing Relationships

James Champy
A commentary by best-selling business author James Champy on how to prevent outsourcing pitfalls and ensure success.

James Champy, Perot Systems chairman of consulting, is a leading authority on organizational change. He is co-author of Reengineering the Corporation, the landmark business text of the 1990s that sold more than two million copies and helped  launch  the  field of  business transformation    management,    and    the    author    of
X-Engineering the Corporation: Reinventing Your Business in the Digital Age. He has moderated programs for the PBS Business Channel and appeared as a guest on the PBS program Wall Street Week, and his columns have appeared in ComputerWorld, Sales & Marketing Management, Fast Company, and Forbes magazines. Read more about James Champy.
 
 
Although outsourcing has gotten a lot of press recently, it's hardly a new phenomenon. More than a century ago, industrialization gave rise to specialization and the practice of companies working for each other. The trend abated briefly when Alfred Sloan developed the famed vertically integrated organization of General Motors, but by the 1950s, competitive pressures had again driven companies to send work beyond their walls.

Given the relentless demand by customers for getting more for less, it's certain that work will increasingly be outsourced to partners around the corner and around the world. As various studies and decades of actual experience have shown, the value added through outsourcing not only benefits the outsourcing provider and customer, but the economy as a whole. Global sourcing is not a zero-sum game.
But as smart a business move as outsourcing usually is, effectively managing the workflow is tricky, since a company’s knowledge accompanies its work-often to another shore. Executives need to avoid common pitfalls to ensure that their outsourcing relationships deliver maximum value. I call them the Seven Deadly Sins of Outsourcing Relationships.

1. Launching an outsourcing relationship without deeply understanding your core competencies versus the work that can most effectively be outsourced.

A key benefit of outsourcing is that it enables a company to focus on the work that is core to its value proposition. Obviously, it is vital to know exactly what that is. That might sound elementary, but the truth is that many companies have only a superficial knowledge of how they truly create value for their customers. If you’re a pharmaceutical company, is your success based on the quality of your research, on your sales and distribution network, on your unique manufacturing capabilities, or on something different altogether?

Don’t be surprised if you find yourself considering outsourcing one of your operational strengths. Although you may be good at something tactically, it still may not be core, and someone else may do it better and at a lower cost.

 

2. Underestimating the importance of process standardization.

Every company begins with the belief that the work it is outsourcing is unique and must be managed uniquely. The company expects its outsourcing service provider to maintain the complexity rather than to simplify and standardize the work processes. Processes and people are moved to the provider in their existing state and are independently managed next to countless similar processes of other companies. Consequently, the cost and service benefits of standardization and simplification are lost.

The reality is that most basic processes are similar from company to company, and service providers must embrace process standardization if they are to help their clients achieve true operational excellence. Twenty years ago, companies argued that their payroll processes were unique, and they spent millions building custom payroll applications and processes. Today, no rational company would consider running its own payroll system-they simply use the standard processes offered by service providers, realizing not only greater efficiency, but also higher quality as a result.

 
3. Not driving for true transparency with your outsourcing partner.

Certain kinds of work involve fairly stable processes, like order fulfillment. But others change over time. Companies may have new application needs in an IT outsourcing relationship or new transactional protocols in a business process outsourcing relationship. In such cases, full transparency between the client company and its service provider is a must.

Managed well, an outsourcing relationship will affect how each partner works as it learns from the other. Work should move seamlessly across corporate boundaries, with breakdowns quickly identified and fixed. This happens only when operational transparency is hard-wired into the relationship from the outset.

 

4. Casting your outsourcing relationship in stone.

No business stands still today. The breakneck pace of change demands flexibility on the part of companies and their service providers. But outsourcing agreements, too often focused solely on cost control, can lock in behaviors that inhibit the nimbleness a client company needs to maintain true operational excellence over time.

A relentless focus on costs will continue to be part of doing business for the foreseeable future, but the scope of outsourcing agreements should be subject to change as the client’s needs evolve. At the same time, a provider has to have minimum commitments to be able to invest in the work of its customers.

 

5. Being too one-sided in your view of the relationship.

The most successful outsourcing relationships-those that lead to long-term value creation for both parties-never lose sight of the fact that the relationship is a bilateral one. Just as the client company seeks to save money, reduce risk, and/or enhance the quality of its operations, the service provider seeks to earn a profit, build on its service capabilities, and leverage its growing expertise for the future.

Fortunately, these goals are complementary. An insurance company, for instance, can not only gain efficiency and quality by allowing a partner to take on much of its back-office policy administration functions, but the added work volume may enable the service provider to accelerate release of the next advancement in the intellectual property it has brought to the relationship-a win-win scenario.

 

6. Not building in sufficient mechanisms to resolve issues.

Outsourcing relationships, like all business relationships, are about people and personalities-and the marriage will inevitably hit a rough patch. This may stem from a management mistake by the client company, a service delivery hiccup by the provider, or some combination of both. Savvy partners, however, anticipate these episodes at the outset and build in mechanisms to guide their behavior when dealing with these issues.

These may include ad hoc councils, defined escalation ladders to take issues up the management rungs, or creative guidelines for issue resolution. But notice the emphasis on “guidelines,” not “laws.” While it’s smart to plan issue resolution approaches early on, they should not be cast in stone, lest they themselves become issues. More important than the specific mechanism is the mutual commitment to resolve issues quickly and amicably.

 

7. Tending the trust-based relationship carefully over time.

Don’t think of your outsourced service provider as a “vendor.” A vendor sells widgets; an outsourced service provider brings you knowledge and skills. Or it may be your knowledge and skills that you transfer and invest in the service provider to take advantage of their superior execution. No matter the specifics of the relationship, it demands a high degree of trust as well as a willingness to look continuously at the work with fresh eyes.

Many business alliances fail either because the parties don’t share the same business values or because there isn’t enough in the deal for everyone. When outsourcing relationships work, however, they can deliver value beyond expectations. So ask some hard questions of your service provider before consummating the deal: How does it treat its people? Its customers? What does it
believe about service quality, innovation, and ethics? And how does it handle the inevitable bumps in the road?

Then structure a relationship where all parties enjoy financial benefits, growth opportunities, and the chance to contribute meaningfully. In business alliances, it’s important to keep good partners strong. With that common ethic, trust will grow as the partnership flourishes.

If executed properly, outsourcing is a win-win situation. The enterprise receives the benefits of best practices expertise and the service provider earns new business opportunities. Taking the time to implement the tactics discussed in this paper will make outsourcing relationships more successful by mutually increasing understanding, transparency, flexibility, communication, and trust.

 
   
 
   
 
Media Relations Contact:

Manish Jain
Sr. Manager - Marketing, Sales and Communication
+91-9841038446

 

VIMS Delivers Process Results and also assists you in taking informed decisions through real-time reports.

Download VIMS PDF




VCIS- Harnessing Knowledge For Improving Process Efficiencies.

Download the PDF

© 1996-2007 Perot Systems. All rights reserved.